Writing: “thinking as hard as you’ll ever think”

Writing is the most exact (and exacting) form of thinking…Good writing is the best kind of conversation you never heard. It’s talking tidied up. It’s speaking compressed, clarified, enriched and heightened by thought and art, and set down on paper. MARK TREDINNICK

I found myself doing a lot of underlining, flagging, and commenting while reading Mark Tredinnick’s Writing Well: The Essential Guide. Tredinnick, an award-winning poet, essayist, and teacher, makes some compelling arguments not only about how to write well, but also about why we must strive to write well. His core directive is nearly identical to that of Strunk and White (whose The Elements of Style I blogged about previously): write clearly and as simply as possible. Tredinnick’s repetition of this directive throughout the book makes Writing Well a bit circular in organization, but Tredinnick nonetheless delivers a guide that offers both practical advice and an explanation of how writing is a thoroughly social act.

Tredinnick’s practical advice on writing is very accessible. Writers of both fiction and non-fiction will discover useful tips, and Tredinnick’s many “Try this” sections could easily be broken down for strategic use in the classroom. He doesn’t offer much on grammar that I didn’t already know (or hadn’t recently encountered in my examination of Strunk and White), but Tredinnick’s insights into the experience and the meaning of writing often struck me as remarkably lucid.

Tredinnick is very sensitive to the many factors that can motivate and distract writers. He is more forthright than most in acknowledging the prevalence and the impact of anxiety and personal constraints among writers. (See his “Try this” tips on pages 26 and 30 for some useful exercises to cope with your own writing anxieties and constraints.) Aside from his core directive to write clearly and simply, which he ties closely to the rejection of opaque, “pompous” language, Tredinnick’s six central writing tips can be summarized as follows:

  • Favor a rough writing plan over a thorough and exact one.
  • Develop your thesis and know what you are going to argue before you begin writing.
  • State your main point upfront; don’t hold it back from your readers.
  • Focusing on the hard work of writing each sentence well will improve your coherence throughout your writing.
  • Perfecting your paragraphs is the next level in improving your overall coherence.
  • All parts of your writing should be linked together–don’t leave your readers with any confusion as to where you are taking them.

Tredinnick also pushes writers to consider the larger significance of the act of writing and connects all his writing tips to the concept of writing as a social act. Writing, Tredinnick asserts, is a deliberate undertaking and a powerful action. It’s a way of sharing ideas, of participating in and shaping democracy and civilization. Too often, he argues, “imperious language [is used] to hold onto knowledge and power” (Tredinnick, Writing Well, 41). Abstract, overly complex language runs counter to the very purpose of writing: the communication of ideas. Consider Tredinnick’s apt spoof of an academic attempt to encourage clear writing:

The fundamental principle for the efficacious elucidation of meaning in documentation is the minimization of abstraction of expression and the abandonment of convolution of construction and, instead, the utilization of quotidian diction and the employment of syntactical simplification (Tredinnick, 61).

Know anyone who writes like that? I do, and I appreciate Tredinnick’s careful efforts to link good writing to clear writing. While he vigorously discourages writers from falling into the habit of writing with detached, “unfamiliar and polysyllabic diction” (which he believes too many writers mistake for “a mark of rank or intelligence or expertise”), he doesn’t advocate the total abandonment of abstraction–merely its rationing (Tredinnick, 70). He recognizes that certain topics lend themselves to a degree of theoretical writing, and he encourages writers to constantly expand their vocabulary so that they may improve their ability to write with precision and dexterity. It’s just that, on the whole, he believes writers need to strive for greater fidelity to clarity and simplicity. “Make the abstract concrete. Make the general particular” (Tredinnick, 110). Write, in other words, the way you’d like to see society run. Aim to write in a way that will get your point across to the broadest spectrum of society possible. Write inclusively, with good manners, respect, and egalitarianism. Write clearly.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s